Debate Scenario

The issue:
Many communities are trying to do their part to reduce the level of black carbon pollution in the air. It is difficult for a small city or town to restrict driving or to impose pollution regulations on trucks and automobiles. However, another source of soot is from the burning of wood in fireplaces and charcoal briquets in barbeques.

Some communities have imposed a ban or sharp restriction on the recreational use of wood-burning fireplaces and barbeques. It is unclear whether these new regulations will be enforceable, nor how effective the new ordinances will be in reducing emissions. However, one could easily argue that these recreational activities are non-essential, and that anything which will help reduce soot production is worth trying.

What do you think?

• Take a position, pro or con. (Your teacher may wish to assign positions.)

• Research the problem.

• Present your argument to students representing the opposing viewpoint.

• Be prepared to rebut the argument presented by the other side.

• Your teacher may ask you to offer alternative solutions or to try to reach a compromise.

Return to ELSI Home Page